Skip to content


Your cart is empty

Article: Good Gemstones for Engagement Rings

A photo of a sparkling diamond engagement ring surrounded by various gemstones.

Good Gemstones for Engagement Rings

Choosing the perfect gemstone for an engagement ring can be a daunting task. There's so much more to consider than just beautiful colors and sparkle - durability is crucial too! This article will guide you through the top choices of gemstones, their pros and cons, and important factors to consider when selecting one for your future engagement ring.

Continue reading as we unfurl the world of gleaming gems meant to suit every taste and preference. 

Understanding Gemstone Engagement Rings

A hand holding an engagement ring against a backdrop of gemology books.

Gemstone engagement rings offer unique alternatives to traditional diamond rings, but before making a decision, it's important to understand the benefits and risks associated with choosing gemstones.

One key factor to consider is the durability of different gemstones, which can be measured using the Mohs Hardness Scale.

Benefits and Risks

Gemstone engagement rings come with their own unique set of benefits and risks, making it important to consider them before making a purchase.

Benefits Risks
Gemstone engagement rings offer variety in color and style not often found in traditional diamond rings. Some gemstones, like amethyst and opal, lack durability and are prone to damage in everyday usage.
Due to their unique styles and larger sizes, gemstone rings can be more eye-catching than traditional diamond rings. Opals, despite their stunning beauty, are too soft and can easily break during normal wear.
Compared to diamonds, gemstones can be more affordable, making them a budget-friendly choice. Morganite engagement rings tend to show dirt and oil easily, which can affect their sparkle and appearance over time.
Gemstones like sapphire, emerald, ruby, and aquamarine are durable, with a hardness rating of 7.5/10 or higher on the Mohs Scale, suitable for daily wear. Pearl engagement rings, though elegant, are not recommended for engagement rings due to their softness and susceptibility to chips and scratches.


Durability and the Mohs Hardness Scale

A woman wearing a sapphire engagement ring enjoying outdoor activities.

Durability plays a key role in choosing the right gemstone for your engagement ring. Consider this: you're likely to wear this token of love daily, which means it needs to withstand everyday activities.

Enter the Mohs Hardness Scale - a chart that measures the toughness of minerals on a scale from 1 (softest) to 10 (hardest). Diamonds earn the top spot with a ten out of ten rating.

However, diamonds aren't solely holding court as scratch-resistant rocks; some non-diamond gemstones also make significant marks on this scale. For instance, sapphire and ruby both boast an impressive score of nine out of ten, representing their strong resistance against scratches even during daily wear.

A hardness rating above 7.5 is generally considered excellent for gemstone engagement rings meant for regular use.

Top 5 Gemstones for Engagement Rings

Top 5 gemstones for engagement rings

emerald engagement ring in a vibrant nature setting.

Choosing the right gemstone for an engagement ring requires considering both beauty and durability. Here are the top five gemstones that strike this balance:

  1. Sapphire: Sapphire, whether it's a blue sapphire or a peach sapphire, offers style and strength with a Mohs hardness scale rating of 9 out of 10. Its wide range of colors from pink to green makes it ideal for unique engagement rings.
  2. Ruby: As another non-diamond center stone with a Mohs hardness scale rating of 9, ruby symbolizes passion and love, making it an excellent choice for romantic engagements.
  3. Emerald: With its lush green hue and symbolism of love and prosperity, emerald adds a vintage touch to any engagement ring. Despite its lower Mohs hardness scale rating compared to sapphire and ruby, proper care will ensure its longevity.
  4. Aquamarine: If you're looking for something that screams oceanic beauty in your gemstone engagement rings, aquamarine is your go-to gemstone It's as durable as emerald but offers a different aesthetic with its cool blue tones.
  5. Morganite: Last but not least on this list is morganite, the stone of divine love. While softer than other stones on this list with a comparable hardness to emerald and aquamarine, morganite’s striking pink or peach hue promises an eye-catching piece fit for daily wear.


Sapphire: A Timeless Classic

A sparkling sapphire ring is showcased amidst a vibrant floral arrangement.

Sapphire, known for its captivating blue color, is a timeless classic choice for an engagement ring.

Features of Sapphires

A woman wearing a striking sapphire necklace in front of a city skyline.


Sapphire holds a distinguished position among gemstones, celebrated for its rich history and timeless beauty. The vibrant hues of blue sapphire are widely recognized, with each shade offering unique charm and appeal in engagement rings.

However, sapphires also come in an array of other captivating colors, including yellow, pink, green and peach. Hailing from various parts of the world like Australia, Burma or Kashmir impacts the color intensity as well as value of this precious stone.

Sapphire gets a high score on Mohs Hardness Scale (9 out of 10), making it one of the toughest non-diamond gems available. This durability makes it resistant to scratches and damage while handling daily wear effortlessly; hence it's highly preferred for engagement rings.

Its mineral content offers varied options ranging from Star Sapphires showcasing beautiful asterism to cabochon cut ones that are polished but not faceted.

Pros & Cons of Sapphires

A vibrant still life photo featuring a sparkling sapphire ring and colorful gemstones.

Sapphire gemstones are a popular pick for engagement rings due to their beauty and durability, but like all gemstones, they have their pros and cons.

Pros Cons
Sapphires have a hardness rating of 9/10 on the Mohs Scale, making them extremely durable and resistant to scratches. This makes them perfect for everyday wear. Despite their durability, sapphires can still crack or chip if hit with enough force. This is especially true for stones with inclusions.
Sapphires are available in a wide range of colors, allowing for personal customization. High-quality, colored sapphires can be quite expensive, especially those in rare colors.
These gemstones have a timeless appeal that never goes out of style, making them a safe and stylish choice for an engagement ring. Some might find sapphires to be too traditional or lack the unique factor, as they are a common choice for engagement rings.


Emerald: The Stone of Love and Prosperity

A woman wearing an emerald necklace stands in a lush garden.

Emerald, known as the "Stone of Love and Prosperity," is a captivating gemstone with its lush green color and rich symbolism.

Features of Emeralds

A woman wearing an elegant emerald necklace stands in a lush green garden.

Emeralds are captivating gemstones known for their stunning green color. These precious stones belong to the beryl family, which also includes aquamarine and morganite. With a hardness rating of 7.5-8 on the Mohs Scale, emeralds are reasonably durable and can withstand daily wear.

Their rich green hue symbolizes growth, fertility, and rebirth. Emerald engagement rings offer a unique and vibrant alternative to traditional diamond rings, making them perfect for those looking for something different.

Believed to bring harmony, balance, and good fortune, emeralds have been cherished throughout history by ancient civilizations. Whether set in a simple solitaire or paired with sparkling diamonds, an emerald engagement ring is sure to make a statement of love and elegance.


Pros & Cons of Emeralds

A woman wearing an emerald engagement ring surrounded by greenery.

Emerald engagement rings offer a blend of history, style, and symbolism. However, like all gemstones, they come with their set of benefits and drawbacks. Here's a quick summary of the pros and cons of choosing an emerald for your engagement ring.


Pros Cons
Emeralds are associated with love and prosperity which makes them an ideal choice for an engagement ring. Emeralds are prone to inclusions, visible flaws within the stone, which might affect the overall appearance of the ring.
Emeralds are gaining popularity for their unique style, large size, and lower cost compared to some other gemstones. Emeralds rank 7.5 and above on the Mohs Hardness Scale, which means they must be treated with care to prevent chipping or scratching.
With a score of 7.5/10 on the Mohs Hardness Scale, emeralds are durable enough to stand up to daily wear. Due to their natural color, emeralds may not be as sparkly or reflective as other gemstones like diamonds or sapphires.


Remember, the final choice for your engagement ring gemstone should reflect your personal taste and lifestyle.

Ruby: Symbolizing Passion and Love

A woman wearing a ruby necklace stands in a field of red roses.

Ruby is a gemstone that symbolizes passion and love, making it an ideal choice for an engagement ring.

Features Of Rubies

A couple embraces on a scenic overlook, showcasing a ruby engagement ring.

Ruby, a stunning gemstone symbolizing passion and love, is an excellent choice for engagement rings. With its vibrant red color and exceptional hardness of 9/10 on the Mohs Scale, rubies are highly resistant to damage and chipping.

These precious stones provide a unique alternative to traditional diamond rings, adding a touch of vibrancy and romance to any design. Whether set in yellow gold for a timeless look or paired with platinum for a modern twist, ruby engagement rings offer versatility and elegance.

Let the fiery glow of rubies capture your heart as you embark on your journey of everlasting love.

Pros & Cons of Rubies

Ruby engagement rings come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages. These should be carefully considered before making a purchase decision.


A couple admiring an engagement ring in a beautiful garden setting.
Pros Cons
Ruby symbolizes passion and love, making it a meaningful choice for an engagement ring. Ruby engagement rings typically command a higher price compared to some other gemstone options.
One of the hardest non-diamond gemstones, ruby is less likely to chip or be damaged. Ruby requires regular maintenance and cleaning to maintain its vibrant red color.
The vibrant red color of ruby is highly desired and stands out among other gemstone rings. Some may find the vibrant red color of ruby too bold or flashy for their taste.
Ruby can be paired with other gemstones for a unique and personalized engagement ring design. The color of the ruby might not match easily with all other gemstones or ring metals.
Ruby is considered timeless and can be passed down through generations as an heirloom piece. Some may prefer more contemporary or trendy gemstones over the classic ruby.
It is believed that wearing a ruby brings good fortune and protection to the wearer. These spiritual beliefs associated with ruby might not align with everyone’s personal beliefs or preferences.


Aquamarine: A Touch of Oceanic Beauty

A photo of a shimmering aquamarine pendant necklace with a serene ocean sunset backdrop.


Aquamarine is a gemstone that exudes the beauty of the ocean with its captivating blue hues and sparkling clarity.

Features of Aquamarine

An underwater shot of vibrant coral reefs with diverse marine life.

Aquamarine is a gemstone that stands out for its oceanic beauty. With a hardness rating of 7.5/10 and above on the Mohs Hardness Scale, aquamarine is durable enough to withstand daily wear.

This pale blue gemstone offers couples a unique and vibrant color option for their engagement rings. Its soothing hue captures the essence of tranquility, making it an excellent choice for those who seek a calm and serene aesthetic.

Aquamarine's light-reflecting properties bring sparkle and radiance to any setting, creating an eye-catching piece of jewelry that will surely be cherished forever.

Pros & Cons of Aquamarine

Aquamarine is a striking gemstone that offers a unique element of charm and beauty to an engagement ring. However, like any gemstone, it carries its own set of pros and cons that should be considered before choosing it for an engagement ring.


Pros Cons
Due to its oceanic beauty, aquamarine can provide a unique touch to an engagement ring. Aquamarine is relatively soft compared to other gemstones and may get scratched or damaged if not handled carefully.
Aquamarine is a durable gemstone with a Mohs Hardness Scale rating of 7.5/10, suitable for daily wear. Its distinctive blue color may not appeal to everyone and can limit the color options for the engagement ring.
It is an affordable gemstone, making it a cost-effective option for larger stone engagement rings. Because it is not as hard as sapphire or ruby, it might not be the best choice if durability is a priority.


When choosing an engagement ring, it's crucial to weigh the pros and cons of each gemstone in order to select one that will not only suit your personal style but also withstand the test of time.

Morganite: The Stone of Divine Love

A woman wearing a delicate morganite necklace surrounded by blooming flowers.

Morganite is a beautiful gemstone known as the "Stone of Divine Love" due to its soft, feminine pink color and its association with unconditional love and compassion.

Features of Morganite

Morganite is a captivating gemstone that exudes an air of romance with its soft pink hue. As a form of beryl, it is prized for its beauty and symbolism, earning the title of the "Stone of Divine Love." With a hardness rating of 7.5-8 on the Mohs scale, Morganite is durable enough to withstand regular wear, making it an excellent choice for engagement rings.

Named after J.P. Morgan, this gemstone has gained popularity due to its stunning color, high clarity, and relatively affordable price tag. It is often heat-treated to enhance its color intensity, so it's important to inquire about any treatments when considering purchasing a Morganite engagement ring.

Pros & Cons of Morganite

Morganite, with its soft pinkish hue, is a captivating gemstone that has gained significant popularity in recent years. However, it comes with its own set of advantages and disadvantages when it comes to engagement rings.

Pros Cons
Morganite displays a beautiful, feminine pink hue that many find appealing. Due to its lower hardness, morganite is prone to damage and scratches.
The gemstone is relatively affordable compared to other gemstones like sapphire or diamond. Morganite engagement rings can show dirt and oil easily because of their light color and lack of significant sparkle.
For those seeking unique and unconventional engagement rings, morganite offers an appealing alternative. The gem is not recommended for everyday wear, as it may not withstand long-term use.


While morganite's unique color and affordability make it an attractive choice, these benefits must be weighed against its vulnerability to damage and potential lack of longevity.

Gemstones to Avoid for Engagement Rings

A close-up shot of a diamond engagement ring on a velvet background.

Gemstones such as opals, pearl, amethyst, tanzanite, and others are not recommended for engagement rings due to their lower hardness and risk of damage. These gemstones are too soft and prone to breakage, chipping, or showing dirt easily. It is important to choose a gemstone with durability and strength to withstand daily wear without compromising its beauty.

How to Choose the Perfect Gemstone for Your Ring

A woman wearing an elegant ring with a sparkling gemstone.

Choosing the perfect gemstone for your ring involves considering several factors. First, you should look at the hardness of the gemstone. It is recommended to choose a gemstone with a hardness rating of 7.5 or higher on the Mohs Hardness Scale to ensure durability and resistance to everyday wear and tear.

Next, consider your personal preferences in terms of color and symbolism. Each gemstone carries its own unique meaning and significance, so choose one that resonates with you and complements your style.

Another important factor is the quality of the gemstone. Look for gems with good clarity and color grading, as these factors greatly influence their overall beauty. Additionally, consider whether you prefer natural or lab-grown gemstones, as both options have their own advantages.

Lastly, think about your budget and how much you are willing to invest in your engagement ring. Keep in mind that certain precious stones like diamonds tend to be pricier than semi-precious alternatives.

By carefully considering these factors, you can select a gemstone that not only looks stunning but also fits seamlessly into your lifestyle and represents your love story beautifully.


A couple enjoying a scenic mountain hike on a sunny day.

In conclusion, when choosing a gemstone for your engagement ring, it's important to consider durability and hardness. Gemstones with a Mohs Hardness rating of 7.5 or higher, such as sapphire, emerald, ruby, aquamarine, spinel, alexandrite, and topaz are great options that offer both beauty and strength.

By selecting one of these gemstones for your ring, you can be sure that it will withstand daily wear and symbolize your love for years to come.


1. What are some good gemstones for engagement rings?

Some good gemstones for engagement rings include green, peach, blue, yellow, orange and pink sapphires, tourmaline, spinel, ruby, peridot, garnet and emerald.

2. Are lab-created diamonds a good option for engagement rings?

Lab-created diamonds are a popular diamond-alternative gemstone choice due to their durability and eye-clean gems quality.

3. Can I have an ethically sourced diamond or other recycled precious metals in my engagement ring?

Yes! Many jewelry brands like Brevani and James Allen offer options like ethically sourced diamonds and recycled precious metals as part of their American-made Jewelry line.

4. How can I protect the gemstone on my engagement ring?

Protective settings are great ways to ensure your stone stays safe from damage; also regular care with cleaning is advised to preserve its luster.

5. Can I get an appraisal from a Gemologist before purchasing my engagement ring?

You should always consider getting an appraisal by a certified Gemologist to make sure you're paying the right price based on the gem's durability, cut, origin, hardness etc.

6. Is it possible to design a custom ring with colored diamonds like yellow or pink ones?

Absolutely! Different jewellers offer customized designs where you can choose from various colored stones including rare varieties like yellow diamonds or pink diamonds.